Total Pageviews

Friday, September 18, 2026

Basketball - "Shut Up and Dribble" - The Controversy That Will Never Disappear

Sport is a microcosm of life. In theory, management and players have freedom of speech. In practice, neither has freedom from consequences.

Build a Foundation 

Educate ourselves. A visceral (gut) feeling about a topic is not necessarily an informed one. As difficult as it sounds, learn about both sides of an argument to avoid "confirmation bias" - reinforcing our beliefs with like-minded opinions.

Define Beliefs, Attitudes, and Values 

Beliefs, attitudes, and values are foundations for our personal philosophy. Recognize that beliefs are not 'truth'. We can believe the earth is flat or that dinosaurs lived 6,000 years ago, but neither mesh with the evidence. 

We could establish our chief value that "cats shall inherit the earth." Most people might consider that an odd choice. Establishing that as a core value is personal. 

Actions and Consequences

Everyone recognizes that 'freedom of speech' is not absolute. Speech can carry legal consequences for threats, defamation, fraud, incitement, and certain other narrowly defined categories. 

Current controversies surrounding music personalities and the Houston Texans and Kyrie Irving show the complexity and emotion enveloping all disciplines and geopolitics. 

Practical Applications

Cognitive dissonance explains the difficulty and psychological discomfort in holding opposing viewpoints simultaneously. Maturity includes tolerating the discomfort of mixed judgments. You can admire the player and reject the opinion. You can dislike the speaker and concede the point.

Stoicism reminds us that we are not obligated to hold an opinion on everything. 

Likewise, we are not obligated to share our opinion, recognizing opinions spark controversy.

A team, employer, sponsor, fan, teammate, or consumer may react to speech in ways the Constitution does not prohibit. An employer may consider our words a "fireable offense" or a governing body might pull our license. 

Legal constraints such as libel and slander also might constrain our communication. It is noteworthy that political speech from some elected officials has protection. 

Cancel Culture 

"Cancel culture" applies when organizations or individuals are boycotted or shunned because of their publicly held beliefs. It's people imposing social or economic consequences on speech they consider unacceptable.

"I'm done with him" or "Bye, Felicia." 

Decades ago, Toshiba sold super-secret submarine quieting technology to the Soviet Union. I chose not to buy Toshiba products, not exactly a company-breaker.

Wealthy organizations and basketball superstars often choose not to comment on politics not wanting their "ox to be gored." That's rational to avoid offending fans with different beliefs, attitudes, and values. It's probably more the norm than the exception. 

No Easy Answer

One question is "why should we care about celebrity opinion?" A talking head says, "Shut up and dribble" and we can agree, disagree, or choose to ignore both the source and the target.

Each of us sets boundaries for our attitudes, choices, and effort. Many of us learn "children should be seen and not heard" and later "never discuss religion and politics." Life shows us that both are violated consistently. 

Before speaking, ask three questions:

  • Do I know enough?
  • Does this need to be said?
  • Am I prepared to own the consequences?

Know what you believe and why you believe it. Choose our words and opinions carefully and be prepared to stand behind them. 

Lagniappe. Learning to overcome adversity is both essential and a process.  

 

 

 


 

   

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted by at